From our farm to your table.
100% Handmade from scratch
at White Post Farms!
Experience the comforting taste of tradition with homemade pies from White Post Farms of Melville. Each pie is baked fresh with care using the finest ingredients. From our classic “The Big Apple”, rich “Harvest Pumpkin” to sweet “Dark Chocolate Pecan”, every bite delivers the warmth and flavor of true homemade goodness. Whether you’re picking one up for a family gathering, holiday celebration, or just because, White Post Farms’ homemade pies bring a little piece of Long Island farm freshness right to your table.
Apple Rhubarb & Berries
Apple Rhubarb & Berries Crumble
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Coconut Custard
Dark Chocolate Pecan
Harvest Pumpkin
Old Fashioned Apple Crumb
Orchard Blueberry Crumb
Orchard Blueberry
Peach Raspberry Crumb
Pippen's Pride Cherry
Pippen's Pride Cherry Crumble
Southern Peach Bliss
Southern Peach Crumble
Southern Pecan
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble
The Big Apple
Sea Salt Caramel Applenut
Salted Caramel Apple
Pretzel Streusel Crumble
Stop by the farm market today to browse our ready-made selections or place an order to pick up a fresh pie for the holidays! Our pies make great corporate thankyou gifts. Save a turkey this year and give one of our delicious pies to your favorite employees or customers instead.
Check out our interview on
"Good Day New York"!
Frequently Asked Questions
Each Pie feeds 6 – 8 people.
9 inch deep dish, 42+ oz per pie
Bake at 325° for 15 minutes.
Bake at 350° for approximately 70-75 minutes.
All pies should be consumed within 5 days.
Yes, our pies freeze extremely well.
Put directly in a preheated oven at 325° for 40 minutes.
Please note that our Pumpkin, Pecan and Dark Chocolate Pecan Pies do not need to be reheated.
Every pie is individually boxed. For distribution, there are 6 pies in the transport box.
Yes, our Pumpkin Pie requires refrigeration.
you may store your pies in the freezer for up to 3 months.
Yes, every box displays a list of ingredients.
Yes, we offer our Original Banana Bread, Banana Nut Bread, Banana Dark Chocolate Bread, Garden Zoochini Bread, and Chocolate Chip Cookies with a gluten-free option.
Yes, some do, as indicated on the product labels. Our products are manufactured in a facility that uses tree nuts, eggs, soy, and wheat.